An Old War Dogs Satellite Site
Proud Veteran-American? Please Don't Miss Veterans as an Ethnic Minority
Monday, 27 November 2006
Centcom says AP’s "Iraqi police source" isn’t Iraqi police

See previous: L.A. Times reprinting enemy propaganda?, Milbloggers Weigh in on the Flawed L.A. Times Story on the “Airstrike” in Ramadi

Bombshell: Centcom says AP’s Iraqi police source isn’t Iraqi police
Allahpundit

I laid off this post at Flopping Aces initially because I didn’t think there was anything particularly suspicious about the cop. Centcom was disputing his report of the six Sunnis burned alive by Shiites but they could have been wrong just as easily as he could. I also didn’t (and still don’t) see Curt’s point about the cop only being quoted in cases where Shiites attack Sunnis. If he’s stationed in an area where Shiite attacks on Sunnis are common, that’s going to happen.

But go see his latest update, all the way at the bottom. And bear in mind — the AP’s been using this guy for months.

Like Patterico said about that L.A. Times airstrike story that’s imploding at an ever accelerating rate:

[...]

Goldstein thinks this is evidence that the violence in Iraq isn’t pandemic, which is a lot further than I’m willing to go. But he’s always worth reading, so partake. Centcom, meanwhile, is demanding a retraction from the AP. They haven’t, to my knowledge, demanded one from the L.A. Times, but Patterico sort of has. Response thus far: zero. ...

Per email from Curt, his site has a bad habit of crashing when he gets heavy traffic. If the link in Allahpundit's post doesn't work click here.

***

Whether you can get to Curt's post or not, don't miss SeeDubya's excellent related post here.

***

Willful Suspension of Disbelief, redux
Jeff Goldstein

From Curt at Flopping Aces comes the news many of us quietly expected:  Centcom has confirmed that Capt. Jamil Hussein, the primary source for the recent kerosene mosque murder reports—and for a whole host of reports of Shia massacres recounted by the AP—is neither an employee of Iraq’s Ministry of Interior nor is he a police captain.

In short, the AP has been relying on a bogus source for much of its reporting on Shia violence against Sunnis since at least April.

For those who continue to suggest that the mainstream press has a negligible impact on elections, consider that the majority of Americans who bothered to pay any attention whatsoever to this story will be left with an account of horrific sectarian violence against women and children—and the belief that sectarian strife in Iraq is not only inexorable and savage, but pandemic.

Underlying this reportage, then, is an unseemly subtext:  that Arabs in Iraq—and perhaps even Arabs in general—are incapable of working toward a free society, one that, through a series of ratified political documents and elections, has merely pretended to be taking its first tentative steps toward the acceptance of a baby pluralism.  Consequently, the blood and treasure spent in Iraq has never been worth the cost, and—our failure now all but imminent thanks to a genetic or systemic flaw in the Arab constitution—we should be therefore be looking for a way to retreat with honor.  Or perhaps a way to reinstall Saddam Hussein.  You know, to stabilize things.

Whether this narrative is the product of willful distortion or merely the laziness that comes with being fed stories that match your preconceptions is almost beside the point when it comes to effect—though the former is clearly more despicable, and, should it prove to be the case, has the practical effect of undermining a representative democracy that can only work properly if citizens are being given accurate accountings of events by those purporting to do so.  ...

***

Michelle has an excellent related post here. Read it all.

***

See also: Video: NBC declares ‘civil war’ in Iraq

***

Power Line has more here, including a copy of CENTCOM's news release pertaining to this subject.

*** Update and bump. Previous timestamp 12:33

Does AP Iraqi writer Qais al-Bashir have super powers?
SeeDubya

It's looking like AP Baghdad correspondent Qais al-Bashir is the only one who can see this mysterious, non-existent "Captain Jamil Hussein". Well, it's not for certain yet, but al Bashir is the common element in four stories involving Captain Snuffleupagus. Er, Jamil Hussein: ...

***

Part 1 of a series, as it turns out. Part 2 is here.

Posted by Bill Faith on November 27, 2006 at 07:10 PM in Iraq, Islamism Delenda Est, Jamilgate, Media Malpractice | Permalink

Comments



Post a comment

Comments accept simple HTML for formatting and linking.

Comments are moderated and may not appear on the site immediately. Comments in violation of our comment policy will never appear on the site.







TrackBacks


TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451e4ed69e200e55083654d8834

Trackbacks are moderated and do not appear immediately. Trackbacks from posts that do not link to this post will be deleted and will never be visible here.

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Centcom says AP’s "Iraqi police source" isn’t Iraqi police:

"Centcom says AP’s "Iraqi police source" isn’t Iraqi police" from Old War Dogs
This is gonna leave marks, folks, on some very deserving asses. Click here to go to my Bill's Bites post, follow the See previous ... links for background, read the latest, then check back for more later. We have lift-off [Read More]

Tracked on Nov 27, 2006 12:56:42 PM

"AP uses Questionable Sources for Reporting Iraq Attrocities" from The American Pundit
The Associated Press has apparently been using bogus sources as sources for their reports on attrocities that have occured this year in Iraq. CENTCOM sent a letter to the Associated Press, under the classification of unclassified, informi... [Read More]

Tracked on Nov 27, 2006 4:58:08 PM

"America is in a Civil War, Right Here at Home!" from Webloggin
We are in a civil war here in America and we did not know it. Matter of fact, we are in several. The Bloods and the Crips are two rival gangs that fight over turf (geographical sections) and they are both in this nation. ... [Read More]

Tracked on Nov 28, 2006 6:30:00 AM